Shared ownership left me £16,000 worse off and unable to sell

For plenty of aspiring owners, shared ownership has been a good way to take the first step onto the property ladder with a small deposit.

But as many have found, issues can come up later whenever you attempt and sell your house.

Samantha Henry has been struggling to shift her shared ownership flat for nearly two years.

The 40-year-old entrepreneur was initially very excited to have the ability to purchase a 25% share of a £465,000 one-bed flat in 2018, in Hornsey, north London.

But she’s since misplaced half of her deposit and all the cash she put into her mortgage – and remains to be struggling to sell up.

“At the time this felt like a dream, particularly because the flat was in a constructing which allowed canine,” Samantha defined.

“I used to be in my mid-thirties and lastly residing by myself. I knew it was the house for me. But once I got here to sell, it become one thing of a nightmare.”

With shared ownership, you buy a share of a property, and then pay hire on the remaining quantity to a landlord, often to a housing affiliation.

You can begin off with 25% which you’ll then enhance at a later date by way of ‘staircasing.’

Samantha purchased a 25% share of her flat from Sanctuary Homes, with a ten% deposit of £11,625.

“Over the years, each the hire and service prices have gone up,” she mentioned. “The mixture of mortgage, hire, service prices and family payments means there’s rather a lot to funds for. My monetary circumstances imply I’ve not been in a position to staircase.”

Samantha needed to sell so she might transfer to Essex to be nearer to her household. It’s now turn out to be pressing.

Samantha Henry. Credit: Tatlers, Crouch EndThe most up-to-date estimates worth Samantha’s house at round £40,000 – £65,000 lower than she paid for it [Credit: Tatlers, Crouch End]

She mentioned: “This is sort of urgent now, as my stepfather died in 2022, my sister is absolutely unwell, and my mum wants assist.

“I additionally run my canine equipment enterprise, Pup Chic Boutique, from my flat, it will get fairly arduous whenever you stay and work in such a small area. I desperately want a property with a second bed room.”

When Samantha first launched into promoting in March 2021, the housing affiliation stipulated she had to pay for an unbiased valuation by a surveyor from RICS.

Nathan Emerson, from property agent physique, Propertymark, explains: “The largest drawback of shared ownership is the ‘mechanism to go away it.’ The means of promoting will not be simple. You have to get an expert valuation from RICS, and the surveyor will advise on the worth of the property.”

The housing affiliation will then use this to set the sale worth.

Emerson added: “This could cause points if a possible purchaser provides lower than the valuation determine. It might probably even put you susceptible to discovering your self in damaging fairness if the value has fallen whenever you come to sell. You might find yourself with lower than what you presently owe in your mortgage – and a stability to discover.”

Initially, the surveyor informed Samantha her property was price £415,000, however when she identified a neighbour had simply offered an an identical flat for £440,000, he agreed to enhance hers to the identical quantity.

Samantha mentioned: “While I used to be nonetheless promoting at a loss, I took solace from the very fact I used to be going to get my deposit again, and had saved cash in contrast to renting within the space.”

If you need to sell a shared ownership house, you’ll be able to advertise at any time, no matter your share. Those who personal 100%, can often sell it on the open market via an property agent.

If, nonetheless, you personal much less, you could notify your landlord so as to give them an opportunity to discover an eligible purchaser in your share – referred to as a ‘nomination interval.’

The improvement in Hornsey, north London [Credit: Tatlers, Crouch End]

Pete Mugleston from onlinemortgageadvisor.co.uk, mentioned: “This is often 4, eight or 12 weeks, relying on the lease. If the owner does discover a purchaser, the sale worth will likely be not more than the present market worth of your share. If no purchaser is discovered inside this era, you’ll be able to sell your share your self on the open market.”

Samantha was required to give Sanctuary Homes eight weeks to attempt and sell her flat.

“But I didn’t have any viewings throughout that point,” she mentioned. “When this era was up, I then had to get written affirmation that I might enlist the assistance of an property agent.”

Initially, Samantha employed a high-street agent, however regardless of getting numerous viewings, there was no curiosity. She then modified to a extra native agent who discovered a purchaser inside a month.

“This was nice information, as by the point I received a suggestion, in January 2022, I had reserved a home that I favored in Halstead, Essex,” she mentioned. “This was one other shared ownership house.”

At this stage, Samantha bumped into difficulties once more, as after paying for a brand new valuation, the customer subsequently disappeared. This resulted in her shedding the home in Halstead.

Just just a few weeks later, in April, the property agent discovered a brand new purchaser, wanting to buy with a 100% mortgage.

“As this was not a shared ownership purchaser, the foundations stipulated I had to pay for a valuation with the housing affiliation’s chosen valuer,” mentioned Samantha. “In simply over 12 months, I ended up spending nearly £1,000 on valuations. I additionally misplaced £500 on the deposit I’d put down on the home.”

In April final yr, Samantha discovered one other property she needed to purchase.

“I fell in love with a good looking countryside place in Coggleshall, Colchester,” she mentioned. “As all the things appeared to be going effectively with the customer for my Hornsey flat, I went forward with paying for searches. But then my purchaser determined he wanted to pay for one more valuation on my flat.”

When this was carried out in June final yr, Samantha’s flat received valued at simply £400,000. This in the end resulted within the sale falling via.

“The buy of the Coggleshall home additionally fell via,” she mentioned. “It was then a case of getting to return to the drafting board.”

Last autumn, after mortgage charges sky-rocketed, Samantha determined to ask the housing affiliation if she might drop the value of her flat to £400,000. They lastly agreed to this in December.

“Fortunately, in January, I discovered a brand new purchaser for my flat,” she mentioned. “I additionally discovered a brand new home to purchase in Halstead.”

Samantha is now going via the entire house-buying course of once more.

“My primary fear is that my present mortgage supply is simply legitimate till March 2023, so I’m on a deadline to trade,” she mentioned. “The excellent news is, all of the searches have been performed, and the solicitors are working as quick as they will.

“Despite this, I’m not prepared to begin celebrating as a result of a part of me fears it’s all going to come crashing down once more.”

One of the large points for Samantha over the previous two years has been the pace at which issues occur.

“The housing affiliation might be gradual to reply to issues as all the things appears to take ‘10 working days,’” she mentioned. “If a purchaser is buying lower than 100% of the property, they want to be accepted by the owner. All of this takes time.”

“I’m promoting at a loss”

Samantha can also be pissed off that she’s promoting at a loss.

“I now have solely round £5,000 fairness in my flat,” she mentioned. “Not solely am I shedding half of the deposit, however I’m additionally shedding the £9,303 that I paid into the mortgage.

In complete, her losses exceed £16,000.

“My recommendation to anybody contemplating shared ownership is to view it as a longer-term objective. If you may get a spot the place you’ll be able to afford to staircase, and ultimately get to 100%, then I believe it may very well be price it. I believe on this situation, the promoting course of is usually a lot smoother.”

A spokesperson for Santuary Home mentioned: “We will proceed to work with our buyer on the sale of this property and can reassure her that we’re dedicated to providing any help we are able to.”

Important info

Some of the merchandise promoted are from our affiliate companions from whom we obtain compensation. While we intention to function a number of the finest merchandise obtainable, we can’t overview each product available on the market.

Read extra